How to tackle the pre-release resource booklet: read the sources, weigh stakeholders, evaluate options and justify a decision in the extended answer.
—
Best score
—
Last attempt
Best attempt progress
0
XP earned
Watch first
Geography Case StudiesHow to answer a 9 mark question in Geography (AQA)
Mr BHow to answer a 9 marker
Key facts
What Paper 3 Section A is
Paper 3 (Geographical applications) is worth 30% of the GCSE
You get a resource booklet 12 weeks before the exam to study. You will not be allowed to take it in, but you get a clean copy in the exam
Sources can include maps at different scales, diagrams, graphs, statistics, photographs, satellite images, sketches, extracts and quotes from interest groups
The final question is an extended answer that needs an evaluative judgement, using more than one theme from units 3.1 and 3.2
How to study the booklet
1. Understand the issue: what is the problem or decision? Where is it, and at what scale?
2. Identify the stakeholders: who gains, who loses (local people, businesses, government, environmental groups)?
3. Map the options: list each option with its costs, benefits and risks
4. Find evidence in each source: numbers, map evidence and quotes you can use
5. Link to what you know: theory and case studies from the course (for example flood management, urban change, resource use)
Answering the extended question
Introduce: state the issue and the decision you will argue for
Develop two or three points for your choice, each backed with evidence from the sources (use figures)
Counter-argument: explain why you rejected another option or how a stakeholder may disagree
Consider both people and the physical environment and the short and long term
Conclude with a clear, justified judgement (the best answers say why the alternative is not as good)
Take care with spelling, punctuation and grammar: marks are given for them in this section
Exam questions — 4 questions · 12 marks
⚡ Geography exam tip: Use the command word. Describe = what it looks like. Explain = give reasons (because, so, which leads to). Assess = weigh up both sides and reach a judgement. Named examples and figures earn the top marks.
1 markStakeholderAQA 8035 style
What is a stakeholder?
A A person or group affected by, or with an interest in, a decision
B A type of map used in Paper 3
C A statistic used to compare countries
D A decision made by the government
1 markUsing evidenceAQA 8035 style
In an extended issue-evaluation answer, which is MOST likely to earn top marks?
A A list of facts copied from the booklet with no decision
B A justified decision supported by evidence from the sources, with a counter-argument
C A very short answer giving only an opinion
D A description of a case study unrelated to the issue
4 marksEvidenceAQA 8035 style
A council plans to build a £12 million flood wall to protect 400 homes. Local farmers oppose it because 60 hectares of farmland will be flooded when water is stored behind it. Give one advantage and one disadvantage of the plan and explain who is affected by each. (4 marks)
Hint: Use the figures. Link each point to a stakeholder.
+40 XP
6 marksExtended judgementAQA 8035 style
Using the information above and your own knowledge, evaluate whether the council should build the flood wall or use soft engineering, such as planting trees upstream and flood warnings. Justify your decision. (6 marks)
Hint: Weigh both options, use the figures, consider stakeholders and give a final decision with a reason.